Let’s talk.

If your site’s traffic graph looks like it just fell off a cliff, you are not alone. The Google Core and Spam Updates that rolled out from August through this month (October 2025) were not a gentle warning. They were an earthquake.

As an agency, our inboxes are full of confused business owners. And they’re all saying the same thing: “But I was creating helpful content! I was answering user questions. So why did I get penalized?”

This is the most painful kind of penalty: the one you didn’t see coming.

The reason it hurts is that Google’s definitions have changed, and they’ve become much, much harsher. In other words, what was considered “low-quality” or “thin” content in 2023 is now being actively classified as spam.

Let me repeat that. It’s not just “low-quality” anymore. It’s “spam.”

This means Google isn’t just demoting your pages; it’s actively de-indexing them. It’s not a quality issue; it’s a policy violation.

So, let’s walk through the chain of thought to figure out if your “helpful content” is actually “accidental spam” in Google’s new, AI-powered eyes.

1. The Core Problem: “Scaled Content Abuse”

The term Google is using for this is “scaled content abuse.”

This is key. The policy doesn’t care how the content was made (human, AI, or a mix). It cares about the intent.

Scaled content abuse is creating many pages for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings, not for the primary purpose of helping users.

You might be thinking, “I’m not a spammer!” But if your strategy was to pump out hundreds of blog posts to try and rank for every possible keyword variation, you may have accidentally flagged yourself.

Here is the 3-step audit we’re running for our clients right now to find this “accidental spam.”

2. The 3-Step “Accidental Spam” Audit

Be honest with yourself as you go through these questions. Your recovery depends on it.

Audit 1: The “Firsthand Experience” Test (The ‘E’ in E-E-A-T)

Google’s “Helpful Content” system is now built around E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trust). The most important new factor is Experience.

Ask yourself: “Was this article written by someone who actually did the thing?”

• This is SPAM (in 2025): A “review” of the “Top 5 Laptops for 2025” that just lists the technical specs and features it copied from Amazon.
• This is HELPFUL: “We Gave 5 Laptops to Our Video Editor for a Week. Here’s a 10-Minute Video of Him Trying to Crash Them (and the One That Survived).”

See the difference? The first is a summary. The second is an experience. If your site is full of summaries with no real-world, firsthand proof (like original photos, videos, or data), you’re in the danger zone.

Audit 2: The AI “Smell Test”

Let’s be clear: using AI is not against the rules. Using AI badly is.

Ask yourself: “Does this sound like a robot wrote it, and a human never touched it?”

You know the “tells” of lazy AI content. It’s the generic, fluffy phrases:

• “In today’s fast-paced digital world…”
• “It’s crucial to…”
• “In conclusion, [Brand Name] is a great choice…”

It’s content that has perfect grammar but zero personality, zero original opinions, and zero new insights. It just rephrases what’s already on page one of Google. This is not “helpful.” It’s just adding to the noise, and Google is now classifying this noise as spam.

Audit 3: The “Scaled Template” Trap

This is the one that trips up a lot of businesses, especially local services and real estate.

Ask yourself: “Did I publish 50 pages that are 90% identical, just to target different keywords or cities?”

This is SPAM:

• Best Agency in Beirut
• Best Agency in Dubai
• Best Agency in Riyadh

…and every single page has the exact same text, with only the city name swapped out.

This is a classic old-school spam tactic called “doorway pages.” The new algorithms are catching this with 100% accuracy. You are telling Google, “I am a manipulator,” even if you thought you were just “doing SEO.”

3. The Fix: It’s a “Prune and Improve” Strategy

So, you found some “accidental spam.” How do you fix it?

You’re not going to like the answer. You cannot just “update” this content.

If you have a basket of fresh fruit and one piece is rotten, you can throw that one piece away. But if 90% of the fruit is rotten, you have to throw out the whole basket. The rot has spread.

Step 1: Prune (The Hard Part) You must be ruthless. Identify every single page that fails the 3-step audit. Don’t try to save it. Don’t just “add a new paragraph.”

You need to delete those pages and let them 404 (or 410).

Yes, delete them. Removing this toxic, low-value content is the only way to signal to Google that you understand the new rules and are no longer a “spammy” site.

Step 2: Improve (The Smart Part) Now, your site is clean. Look at the topics that you deleted. Which ones are actually important to your customers?

Pick the 10 most important topics. Now, instead of 100 bad articles, your job is to create 10 amazing ones.

Invest in your real, human experts. Interview your CEO. Get your technician to film a real “how-to” video. Buy the products and actually test them. Write a case study with real numbers.

One article that demonstrates true, firsthand Experience is now worth more to Google than a thousand generic AI posts.

This isn’t just a content refresh. It’s a complete shift in your company’s mindset. Stop creating content. Start demonstrating your expertise.

If you’re staring at a traffic graph that’s hit rock bottom and you’re feeling overwhelmed, we get it. This is a hard reset for the entire web. But it’s also a massive opportunity for the real experts to finally win.

Ready to make AI data-driven decisions for your brand?

Creatives can help!

Our team of AI-powered digital marketing experts can guide you in harnessing the power of data to achieve your marketing goals.

Schedule a consultation to learn how our AI-powered solutions can drive growth.